DundeeDundee |
2 - 22 - 2 |
AberdeenAberdeen |
|
Scottish Cup (Quarter Final) |
|
| Goalscorers | |
|
Graham Harvey (26) John Brown (65) |
John Hewitt (24) John Hewitt (73) |
| Team Managers | |
|
Archie Knox |
Alex Ferguson |
| Starting Eleven | |
|
1. Bobby Geddes 2. Stewart Forsyth 3. Tosh McKinlay 4. Rab Shannon 5. Jim Smith 6. Jim Duffy 7. Colin Hendry 8. John Brown 9. Graham Harvey 10. Bobby Connor 11. Vince Mennie |
Jim Leighton .1 Stewart McKimmie .2 Ian Angus .3 Neale Cooper .4 Alex McLeish .5 Willie Miller .6 Eric Black .7 Neil Simpson .8 John Hewitt .9 Jim Bett .10 Peter Weir. 11 |
| Bench | |
|
12. John McCormack 14. Stuart Rafferty |
Billy Stark .12 Paul Wright .14 |
| Substitutions | |
|
Stuart Rafferty for Colin Hendry (64) |
Billy Stark for Neil Simpson (58) Paul Wright for Peter Weir (69) |
| Cautions | |
|
Vince Mennie (70) |
Neil Simpson (56) |
| Red Cards | |
| None. | None. |
| Match Officials | |
|
B. R. McGinlay (Balfron) (Referee) |
Newspaper extract from The Courier .
How tragic and ironic that an error by Bobby Geddes should make a necessary Scottish Cup quarter-final replay between Dundee and Aberdeen.
Tragic-that a famous victory should be snatched from Dundee in such cruel fashion.
Ironic - that the mistake was made by a player who has had a magnificent season.
The Dark Blues were just 17 minutes away from a place in the semi-finals when, with the scoreline standing 2-1, the big keeper decided to dribble the ball forward before clearing up the park.
Geddes had, however, failed to see Aberdeen's Neil Simpson who came from behind him, took the ball away and crossed for John Hewitt to head in the equaliser that means Dundee must do it all again at Pittodrie on Wednesday night.
Manager Archie Knox, though understandably disappointed that the game at Dens should have ended 2-2, refused to criti cise his goalkeeper.
His anger was instead directed at the crowd, or rather lack of it. On the eve of Saturday's game he had stated, "I'll be bitterly disappointed if we don't get 20,000."
Well, only 13,188 people turned out and he blasted "That's a disgraceful attendance for a quarter-final, local derby game-What do the fans want?"
Reflecting on the game, Archie said, "The players are sick, they knew it was in our grasp. When we went 2-1 up I couldn't see Aberdeen coming back and thought we were doing enough to get there.
"But we live to fight another day the prize of a semi-final place is still these for us."
Available for the replay will be Bobby Glennie, who has now completed his suspension, and Ray Stephen, who missed Saturday's clash after twisting his knee in training 24 hours earlier.
"Ray would have made it otherwise, the groin injury had improved sufficiently, but he'll be okay for Wednesday night," revealed the Dens Park boss.
Aberdeen's Eric Black and Neil Simpson are suffering from rib injuries, but Joe Miller should be available for the replay.
Manager Alex. Ferguson commented, "Obviously, at 2-1 down I was worried, but it was a great cup-tie and a marvellous game for the fans."
Dundee were the better team in the early stages, but fell behind in 24 minutes when a Black cross eluded Jim Smith before finding the head of John Hewitt.
The Dark Blues, however, bounced straight back and less than 120 seconds later were on level terms when Graham Harvey slid home a cross-cum- shot from John Brown.
Midway through the second period they went in front when Brown headed home after Smith had knocked on a Bobby Connor corner.
For only the second time this season Dundee had turned a deficit into a lead, but it was not to be their day with Hewitt grabbing his and Aberdeen's second.
Archie Knox's side deserved to win this game. They proved that the confidence which abounded at Dens all week wasn't misplaced and can com- plete the job at the second time of asking.
John Hewitt was the sponsor's man of the match, but Bobby Connor proved again that he is one of the best midfield opera- tors around, completely over shadowing the much-vaunted Jim Bett.
Dundee also had sterling service from Graham Harvey, John Brown, Tosh McKinlay and Stewart Forsyth, while the others weren't far behind.
There were two bookings, Simpson for hauling down Connor and Vince Mennie for failing to retreat at a free-kick.
| 1985-86 | All Time | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age | Nat | ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
| Bobby Geddes (GK) | 25 |
|
33 | - | 151 | - |
| Jim Duffy | 26 |
|
33 | - | 33 | - |
| Stewart Forsyth | 24 |
|
10 | - | 25 | - |
| Tosh McKinlay | 21 |
|
20 | - | 109 | 6 |
| Rab Shannon | 19 |
|
32 | 2 | 42 | 2 |
| Jim Smith | 24 |
|
30 | 1 | 158 | 6 |
| John Brown | 24 |
|
26 | 10 | 68 | 21 |
| Bobby Connor | 25 |
|
32 | 2 | 73 | 11 |
| Vince Mennie | 21 |
|
6 | 2 | 6 | 2 |
| Graham Harvey | 23 |
|
28 | 8 | 38 | 10 |
| Colin Hendry | 20 |
|
18 | 1 | 26 | 1 |
| Stuart Rafferty (sub) | 25 |
|
27 | 3 | 71 | 7 |
No league table has been added for this season.
Our match against Clydebank looked easy on paper but there was always the possibility that it was going to be an awkward game but the team did well and applied themselves to continuing the good record we have had this season against the clubs we have been expected to win against. Despite a lot of work being put into making Dens playable the conditions were not ideal but from the word go we adopted the right approach to the match and this set us up to take two more points at home.
Today is Cup day and therefore a special day in the football calendar. We must look to progress and build on results like last week's and although our record here against Aberdeen makes poor reading we must look to get something out of today's game. We cannot hide from our record against Aberdeen but we are certainly a better team than our record would suggest in these matches. It is time to start changing that record and with a semi-final place at stake we have an added incentive.
To me a good Cup run is not reaching the quarter-final stage and bowing out-a good run is getting to the semi-final or going on further. This is what the players must aim for today and hope fully we will progress in the competition.
We should have almost a full squad available and we have had a good build up to today's game and are prepared for this match. We must be the better team over 90 minutes because in these one off matches nothing else matters other than winning. If we are to progress we must beat clubs like Aberdeen and once you have achieved that once it makes the next game against them that wee bit easier.
The players know that nothing but a deter mined performance will do today and with hope fully a full house there should be a real Cup-tie atmosphere.