DundeeDundee |
0 - 20 - 2 |
Dundee UtdDundee Utd |
|
League (Premier Division) |
|
| Goalscorers | |
| None. |
Ralph Milne (24) Ralph Milne (83) |
| Team Managers | |
|
Donald Mackay |
Jim McLean |
| Starting Eleven | |
|
1. Colin Kelly 2. Bobby Glennie 3. Stewart McKimmie 4. Davie Bell 5. Jim Smith 6. Ian MacDonald 7. Iain Ferguson 8. George McGeachie 9. Ray Stephen 10. Peter Mackie 11. Jimmy Murphy |
Hamish McAlpine .1 Derek Stark .2 Maurice Malpas .3 Richard Gough .4 Paul Hegarty .5 Dave Narey .6 Eamonn Bannon .7 Ralph Milne .8 John Reilly .9 Paul Sturrock .10 Davie Dodds .11 |
| Bench | |
|
12. Brian Scrimgeour 14. Eric Sinclair |
John Holt .12 Billy Kirkwood .14 |
| Substitutions | |
|
Brian Scrimgeour for Bobby Glennie (65) Eric Sinclair for Davie Bell (75) |
Billy Kirkwood for John Reilly (75) |
| Cautions | |
|
Iain Ferguson (15) Bobby Glennie (30) |
Maurice Malpas |
| Red Cards | |
| None. | None. |
| Match Officials | |
|
Hugh Alexander (Kilmarnock) (Referee) |
It was almost like old times at Dens. An enormous crowd delayed the kick-off by 10 minutes but, sad to report, that's as close as the Dark Blues came to emulating the good old days.
Next-door neighbours United called the tune with their original party piece. They were different class.
The score flattered the hosts. In fact, if United hadn't been in such benevolent mood, the result would have been embarrassing.
United produced their entire repertoire. Man for man, they could all teach Dundee a thing or two until it came to finishing, that is.
Then it's difficult to make comparisons. Although United squandered numerous opportunities, Dundee didn't create any to miss.
United's midfield dominated from belated start to finish. With that midfield consisting of leading scorer Davie Dodds, defender Derek Stark and Eamonn Bannon, without being disrespectful, it doesn't say much for Dundee's trio of Mackie, Bell and McGeachie.
Certainly, McGeachie looked far short of match practice, but with Bannon at his brilliant best, United were always going to win. Especially when they had someone of the class of David Narey to add to their centre park superiority.
So why only 2-0 at the end of the afternoon? Well, Dundee had stalwart defenders in Jim Smith and Iain MacDonald, who stood up well to most things United could throw at them. But even more significant must be the careless finishing of Sturrock and Reilly.
Both passed up several Hikely openings. Dodds did strike woodwork with a header, but he also shot tamely at Kelly with no one near.
Bannon also missed a glorious chance before the best move of the game produced the first goal of '83 at Dens.
Malpas dispatched a pass up the left touchline to Bannon. Eamonn's near post cross was made to measure and Ralph Milne twisted majestically to glance a superb header well away from the unprotected Kelly.
Dundee fought long and hard and it required an athletic McAlpine clutch to deny Ferguson at the far post with eight minutes remaining. But a goal then would have been a travesty.
As if to take notice of the dangers of being only one goal ahead after so much superiority, United raced to the other end to make sure.
Gough surged forward and drove the ball low and hard across goal. Milne shot, and the ball was deflected in off MacDonald. If it had not been, Dodds was lurking to do the needful anyway.
It was always an exciting tussle, but too one-sided to be a classic.
There were three bookings. Dundee skipper Glennie was noted for hacking down Sturrock in full flight was well justified In fact, Bobby was eventually substituted for his own good
The other two yellow carded can consider themselves very unfortunate. Ferguson tripped Hegarty early on and Malpas did no more than collide with Murphy
United's best were Stark, Gough, Hegarty, Narey and Bannon For Dundee only Smith and MacDonald approached any of the United's XI.
Match report written by The Sunday Post
| 1982-83 | All Time | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age | Nat | ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
| Colin Kelly (GK) | 21 |
|
18 | - | 18 | - |
| Bobby Glennie | 25 |
|
22 | - | 216 | 2 |
| George McGeachie | 23 |
|
11 | - | 143 | 8 |
| Stewart McKimmie | 20 |
|
20 | - | 59 | - |
| Jim Smith | 21 |
|
18 | 1 | 37 | 3 |
| Davie Bell | - |
|
13 | 2 | 34 | 3 |
| Ian MacDonald | 29 |
|
18 | - | 41 | 3 |
| Peter Mackie | 24 |
|
23 | 5 | 128 | 17 |
| Jimmy Murphy | 26 |
|
7 | 2 | 122 | 13 |
| Iain Ferguson | 20 |
|
17 | 9 | 81 | 29 |
| Ray Stephen | 20 |
|
21 | 5 | 79 | 19 |
| Brian Scrimgeour (sub) | 23 |
|
10 | - | 54 | 5 |
| Eric Sinclair (sub) | 28 |
|
21 | 3 | 274 | 90 |
No league table has been added for this season.
First of all let me begin by wishing you all a very Happy New Year. I can only repeat what I have said so often in this page that your support is the most important thing to Dundee Football Club. Directors, managers and players may come and go but without your continued loyal support, it would all be worthless. May I take this opportunity of wishing you whatever you would wish for yourselves this coming year.
Our last home game against Aberdeen was a great disappointment to everyone. Although conditions were far from satisfactory, this cannot be held as an excuse for a very disappointing performance. Even if it did take two questionable goals to beat us, it cannot hide the fact that we did not play particularly well.
Our performance at Love Street however against St Mirren last week was much better and in many ways we were unfortunate to only come away with one point. Overhead conditions were atrocious and it was significant that both teams played better against the wind than with it. But when we remember that St Mirren have some outstanding players in their ranks, I think we should look on this as a point gained rather than one lost as I am quite sure that quite a few teams will come unstuck at Love Street this season.
The injury situation is hopefully beginning to improve with lan Ferguson and George McGeachie both making returns at Love Street last week and Andy Geddes making a welcome return in the reserves against St Mirren on Tuesday. It has been a long hard slog for them but none more so than Andy.
It is always a pleasure to welcome our old rivals from down the street to Dens Park even though in the past few years they have had the upper hand but I can't think of a better way to start 1983 than to reverse that trend today. It is no secret thay have many good players in their ranks but this should act as a stimulant to us today and make us even more determined to get the right result.
Earlier this week I have been involved in a few under-age games and can happily report to you that was very satisfied with the standard of younger players coming to Dens Park. This has got to be the long term future of the club and it takes a lot of time and hard work by people not in the everyday limelight to build up a successful youth policy. I can assure you all that everything is being done to try and insure a flow of good young players coming through. But as have said many times before, it will take time.